But, Timpview High School in Provo decided their mascot was a little tired looking...so they changed it from The Thunderbirds to a Kachina doll. Which, 1) is not logical, and 2) is quite offensive. I mean, its a religious figure. Who changes their mascot TO something offensive? What kind of idiot do you have to be. And, regardless of your position on Indians and Mascots, this is making their Native American students feel hurt and offended. Whatever their intent was--to "honor," --the real thing misses the mark.
So, Principal Bayles:
In a day where people are trying to be more politically correct and more aware of other races, why would anyone change their mascot TO something offensive? The goal for many Native Americans who have taken Indian Mascots to court was to get rid of the offensive mascots, not create more!
If you were afraid your Thunderbird mascot needed to be updated, update the bird--NOT change it entirely!
The statement that your mascot “honors” Indians is completely untrue. If you knew how seriously the Native American people take their history and culture you would not use any part of it for your entertainment. This is a Kachina doll, a religious symbol. It is to be used respectfully, and not to be on display for amusement at high school sports arenas. It is very disrespectful and not at all honorable.
How could an educational institution, whose mission statement is to help "build responsible life-long learners who exemplify integrity" put their own Native American students through this? This is rude, humiliating, and infuriating. I’m sure if you spent as much time asking the Native Americans or even looking up what a Kachina doll is to them, as you did making the offensive mascot, I’m sure you wouldn’t have started.
Please get rid of this offensive mascot as soon as you can.
If you were afraid your Thunderbird mascot needed to be updated, update the bird--NOT change it entirely!
The statement that your mascot “honors” Indians is completely untrue. If you knew how seriously the Native American people take their history and culture you would not use any part of it for your entertainment. This is a Kachina doll, a religious symbol. It is to be used respectfully, and not to be on display for amusement at high school sports arenas. It is very disrespectful and not at all honorable.
How could an educational institution, whose mission statement is to help "build responsible life-long learners who exemplify integrity" put their own Native American students through this? This is rude, humiliating, and infuriating. I’m sure if you spent as much time asking the Native Americans or even looking up what a Kachina doll is to them, as you did making the offensive mascot, I’m sure you wouldn’t have started.
Please get rid of this offensive mascot as soon as you can.
Here are some quotes to think about:
"The Problem in the Non-Indian Community is that many profess a desire to honor Indians, generally through the use of Indian mascots, but in reality, know very little about Indian tribes and tribal members. Usually what they profess to know, is either very little or very wrong. It is difficult to hold someone in high respect and/or esteem, if you know very little about them." Honorindians.com
"Schools and universities are places of learning. These mascots are teaching stereotypical, misleading and, too often, insulting images of American Indians. And these negative lessons are not just affecting American Indian students; they are sending the wrong message to all students."
"An educational institution's mission is to educate, not mis-educate, and to alleviate the ignorance behind racist stereotypes, not perpetuate them and to provide a nondiscriminatory environment for all its students, conducive to learning."
"Imitation, it is said, is the highest for of flattery. But when it is viewed in the eyes of those being portrayed as hostile and abusive—no matter how well-intended—imitation becomes the lowest form of disrespect and insult."
If you want to leave a comment, please leave on at http://www.honorindians.com/ or send me an email and I'll get it to some people collecting letters to give to the school.
1 comment:
In the 90's my oldest brother went to a high school in southern california, his mascot was the "red skins"....I kind of thought people realized how much that doesn't work by now.
Post a Comment